With the ability to receive weak AM transmissions and world wide HF
stations (including SSB for the Sangean ATS505, Eton/Grundig E5/G5,
Sangean ATS909 and Sony ICFSW7600GR),
you will never be without something to listen to and all in a package not much
bigger then a paperback novel.
The following are also worth a mention because of their ability to tune into
most of the HF band, use PLL circuitry and have generous user memory is the -
* Tevion MD81157 from Aldi, shown on the right, not too
bad for the
money at $50 and a better finish than the Sangean ATS505. It
covers LW 144 - 281 kHz, MW, SW 5.85 -17.9 MHz and FM with 240
station memory although in a volatile memory.
With the external aerial modification described later, this is
very useful on the MW broadcast band, better reception than the
radios in our car or caravan by a noticeable margin.
I also describe a 12V power input modification.
And two from Jaycar,
|
* Digitech, Cat No AR1745, (This is a Redsun
RP300), also for $50.
|
It features direct key frequency entry as well as rotary knob and
scan keys, 200 station non volatile memory, all of which is
unusual in a cheap radio and is physically much smaller than all
the others described here, pocket size at only 120x75x28mm.
Frequency coverage is 520-1710 kHz AM, 2300-7500 & 9500-22000
kHz AM and 70-108 MHz FM.

For a compact single conversion radio, it's performance really
surprised me, a very sensitive receiver with reasonable
selectivity right through it's coverage
range. In fact, it's ability to
receive weak signals is the closest thing to my Sony
7600GR that I have come across.
On the down side, common with many others with up/down
button volume control it always turns on and off with an
annoying burst of high level audio (a simple little mod goes
part way to lessening the problem), auto scan only stops
on very strong signals, Local/DX switch doesn't work on MW band
and the whole rational with the way the 200 station memory
has been implemented needs a re-think.
But those criticisms aside, if you are after a radio that
does an above average job of pulling in weak signals that
you can slip into your pocket, this is a ripper.
If this little radio is anything to go by, I'd like to get
my hands on a Redsun RP3000, for bells and whistles it trumps
the Sangean ATS909
by a good margin. There is a Redsun 3100
but minus a few features of the RP3000 such as sync
detector. I don't know what's going on there but
the higher spec RP3000 doesn't feature on their web site (it does exist because I have a photo of both of
them).
|
| |
| *
Kason, Cat No AR1747. (This is a Redsun
RP2100 also sold elsewhere as a Kaito KA2100,
shown on the left.)
|
|
It
is a fully featured receiver (but minus
SSB) for $100.
Like the better ones from Sony and Sangean described above, this
one covers 520 - 29999 kHz, 87 - 108 MHz FM, no LW (below 510
kHz) but this no great loss. It has a 50 station
memory.
More importantly like the Sony and Sangean it is also has dual
conversion but unfortunately misses out on direct key frequency entry.
It is physically
larger than all the others mentioned on this page.
Overseas technical reports are favourable. |
|
| And from Eton/Grundig range is the E5/G5
model for around $225
|
|
|
AM/FM/LW coverage 150 - 29999 kHz,
FM 87.50 - 108 Mhz ( 76 - 108 Mhz User Selectable),
PLL Dual Conversion AM/SW Circuitry with SSB,
700 Programmable Memory Presets,
Alpha-Numeric Four Character Memory Bank Labeling,
Tunes Via Auto-Scan, Manual Scan, Direct Key-in Entry and Tuning Knob
|
*
Their flagship model E1 has the lot including sync
detector, switchable bandwidths and a large dot matrix LCD
but is over three time the price of the
E5/G5. For bells and whistles it also trumps
the Sangean ATS909
by a good margin but at over double the Sangean's
price. (Based on overseas prices because
at the time of writing this I don't believe this E1 model is
available
in Australia.) |
All of the radios described on this page use PLL circuitry with
digital frequency readout.
However be aware that with most cheaper receivers, the inherent
sensitivity (ability to receive weak signals) and selectivity
(ability to discriminate between adjacent signals) is usually comparatively
poor.
Also those cheapies with PLL
synthesisers and microprocessors,
while they may look good on paper, tend to generate considerable internal electrical noise which means
that any weak signals they might have been capable of receiving
are drowned out.
A half decent car radio will
generally out perform most portable receivers in this price
range. If you are paying less than $100 (Aug 08),
don't expect too much. The Redsun RP2100 (Jaycar No
AR1747) and Redsun RP300 (Jaycar No AR1745) are
exceptions.
There are a few "long range" AM radios on the market
too, my
recommendation, save up for one of the four listed earlier or the
RP2100.
As a rough guide, look for a radio with PLL (Phase Locked
Loop) circuitry and digital frequency readout and
preferably one that uses dual conversion.
Also a keypad is highly desirable for direct frequency
entry and it simplifies storing/retrieving your preset
frequencies too.
|
My choice depending on your budget,
- Sony ICFSW7600GR (or maybe the Sangean ATS909)
around $400,
- Sangean ATS505 / Sony ICFSW35 / Eton/Grundig
E5/C5 around $200 - $225,
- Kason (Redsun RP2100) from Jaycar, $100,
- Tevion MD81157 or Redsun RP300 around $50.
(Prices as
at Aug 08)
Why the Sony ? Technically, in my experience, they have the edge (of these small
portable types), they are well made with very good fit and finish
and a solid feel. Most importantly, they have a reputation for
reliability and don't look or feel like they have been thrown
together.
Also a full service manual and spare
parts are available (and I have found Sony Aust to be very helpful
as well).
One feature that sets this Sony apart from most other portables is
the use of a synchronous detector. This is not a gimmick, it
really works. Briefly, a synchronous detector goes a long
way to reducing the effects of signal fade by replacing the fading
carrier with a stable internally generated one.
Also with the Sony's +/- 1.5kHz fine tuning and excellent
frequency stability, the SSB mode can be useful in reducing the
effects of adjacent signal interference by selecting either the
upper or lower sideband as appropriate.
And Sony's flagship ICFSW7600GR is made in Japan too, the only one
here that is, the rest are from China or Taiwan.
How long Sony will continue to make this model is anyone's guess,
mine is that it will eventually be discontinued without being
replaced, the same way their previous flagship model was, the
brilliant SW77.
But I do have some minor quibbles because it doesn't do things the
way I would like it to,
such as the way it performs band scanning (oh for the flexibility
and features of my Icoms but at less than a quarter of the price .
. . ) and those annoying beeps on
confirmations, errors and end of band scans and the wake up alarm
(but very minor surgery fixed that and the wake up to radio alarm
is unaffected).
Unfortunately, Sony doesn't see fit to include an AC power
supply but I describe a cheap solution to that further down the page.
Also the LCD display (I know, that
should be "LC display" ) could show more information but for the most part, it's a great little radio,
never sorry I bought it, it goes with us on all our trips.
|
Use
any external aerial with caution and at your own risk.
Familiarise yourself with the potential dangers.
Do
not use any external aerial while there is even a hint of a threat of a
storm
also
any random crackling noises in the receiver can be an
indication of potential or imminent danger.
Never locate an aerial over or under any power lines. |
This can be and is a very lengthy technical subject but I have
tried to reduce it into just some simple practical
information.
The following is some very basic information on the
three types of external aerials for your radio to improve
reception at your camp site.
Aerials that we are interested in here fall into three broad categories,
loop, long wire and active types.
A very simple yet effective do-it-yourself one I will describe
here is the non-resonant broadband aerial to vastly improve the medium
wave broadcast band reception of weak signals particularly
suited to less sensitive radios.
| Only perform the following modification to a battery only
operated radio not one with a mains connection. |
The essence of this is to wind 3 or 4 turns of insulated wire
directly on to the ferrite aerial rod inside the radio and
terminate the coil ends to a 3.5mm mono or stereo earphone socket which you will have to fit
somewhere in the case of your radio.
If the radio case is metal not plastic, a
stereo socket would be preferable with the coil terminating on the
tip and ring only.
The aerial itself is nothing more than a length of wire forming a
loop terminated in a matching 3.5mm plug.
Theoretically, the antenna loop length should ideally be as long as convenient
but not exceeding 0.1 wavelength at the highest frequency, which
is approximately 18 metres at 1650 kHz.
Obviously 18 metres is not practical for our traveling needs and
in practice a 6 metre (2M+2M+2M) to 9 metre
(3M+3M+3M) loop is good compromise.
Arrange the wire
such that there is a horizontal component for best effect. The
loop, where length is less than 0.25 wavelength, is
directional with maximum pickup in line (not broadside) and is referred to
as a non resonant magnetic loop.
(Conversely, loops where length is greater than 0.5 wavelength
have maximum pickup broadside, same as a ferrite antenna.)
The loop can be contained in or held in a circular of rectangular
shape by any non-metallic support such as PVC conduit etc or just
hung up like a small clothes line to form a "delta loop"
ideally with roughly equal sides.
Alternatively, the loop can be arranged in a diamond configuration
with a non-metallic spreader (a length of 25mm electrical conduit
is ideal) and can be more convenient to erect. A 1.5M
spreader will give you a 4M loop and a 2M spreader will give a 5.5
- 6M loop
This is a very simple basic aerial but nevertheless works very well, is simple to implement, does not require constant
retuning, is highly portable, easy to set up and not too
critical on direction - a good compromise. Also,
loop aerials in general are less susceptible to inference than a long wire aerial.
Whilst it's possible that selectivity may be slightly degraded due to the unmatched
loading effect, this is of little concern since, generally
speaking, we are out in the bush
trying to pick up whatever we can. (Trying to
receive a weak distant signal adjacent to a strong local one is
not a priority in this instance.)
And our antenna needs to be simple and easy to throw up at our
camp site.
Having said that, I haven't noticed any degradation in selectivity
during field testing.
With this modification to a couple of cheap portable radios and
using just 4 metres of aerial wire, stations were picked up
clearly that are totally absent without. The
performance of these radios from the aspect of receiving a weak medium
wave broadcast band AM signal now is as good as if not better my Sony IFCSW7600GR
with just this 4 metre loop.
Unfortunately this is difficult to implement on the IFCSW7600GR, the
ferrite rod is difficult to access and the radio is so jam packed
full that fitting another socket is virtually impossible,
however........the dramatic improvement seen on the cheaper radios
is not seen with the Sony unless using at least a 8-10M loop.
The same goes for inductively coupled loops, good results on
cheaper radios, nowhere near us useful with radios the caliber of
the 7600.
I have performed this mod on a Tevion MD81157 which has a
readily accessible ferrite rod and plenty of room for an antenna socket,
with excellent results. It now pulls in
weaker signals than either my car or caravan radios with just a 4
metre loop.
(Why did I buy the Tevion ? It caught my eye for
$19-95 (usually $49-95) in an Aldi sale that I
attended out of curiosity.)
Caution
- some radios, such as the Sony IFCSW7600GR, that have an
external aerial socket, have a superimposed DC voltage to power an
active aerial. In this case you can not connect a DC
loop to the aerial socket directly, you have to make sure a capacitor is in
series with the loop.
Before you go defacing your radio, wind the turns on the
ferrite aerial rod and just lead them outside the case and connect
it to 4 - 6 M of wire and arrange in a delta fashion as
described with the wire 2 M or more above ground. If you like
the results, you can make the modification permanent.
It will however be the end of any warranty you may have.
Small loops
I am describing these just as a matter of interest, I don't
believe they are quite as suitable for our wandering needs, my
"cloths line delta loop" above takes a lot of beating in
this situation.
This is another type of loop aerial consisting of the aerial wire,
several turns of it, contained in a plastic loop (picture a hulla
hoop) ranging in diameter from 300mm to 450mm.
Generally narrow bandwidth, they are tuned with a variable
capacitor to suit the received frequency. They tend to be
reasonably directional.
The radio needs to be placed in close proximity, usually inside
the loop since, generally speaking, there is no physical
connection needed, they are inductively coupled to the radio.
They are commercially available and are reasonably effective and
the cheaper the radio, the greater the improvement in reception.
There are passive and active (amplified) types.
Picture on the right is an example of a small amplified loop for
the HF band connected to the radio's external input socket.
Then there are small loops (600 - 1200mm) with
inductive or physical connection to the receiver that you can
build yourself, both passive and active.
.
| Non resonant long wire aerials |
Although out in
the bush a length of wire 10 M or more long strung up a few metres
above the ground with one end tied to a tree and the other
attached to the radio's telescopic antenna can be quite effective on the HF and
FM bands, once again, I'd suggest you be
very cautious, especially if there is even a hint of a thunder
activity or if you are picking up random crackles.
Normally only suitable for the HF and FM bands and will have no
effect whatsoever on LW and MW which use the internal ferrite rod
for these bands.
It does however work for a car radio on the MW and FM bands.
However, with the above modification to the radio, a short whip or
length of wire connected to one side of the coil and the other
earthed can give good results for LW and MW but in a camp site
situation, an effective earth may be difficult to
establish.
This works very well on a boat where connection to any underwater metallic
object forms an excellent "earth".
This is probably beyond the scope of an introductory article like
this but later, I may also describe a simple ATU (aerial tuning unit) and
also a tunable active RF preselector (tuned
amplifier) circuit for the MW broadcast band, either of which you
could build yourself, for the more
adventurous.
These are a commercially available non directional (in the
horizontal plane) vertical whips with an amplifier.
The radio would need an aerial input socket, not likely to be
found on cheaper portable radios.
Some have small inductive loops which you place near your receiver
for the LW and MW bands for radios without a suitable input
connector for those bands.
Shown on the right is simple yet effective wideband active
aerial
you can build for under $10 using a 1M vertical whip for ease of use in a
caravan.
|
Modifications to the Tevion MD 81157 receiver
|
This
radio lends itself to very simple "improvements" due to
the liberal amount of free space inside such as the aerial modification described
above and a 9 to 30VDC input, much more convenient than the original
6VDC one for several reasons.
The radio received the above aerial modification and in addition,
one side of the winding is connected to the telescopic aerial so
that the new external aerial works well on all bands, LW & AM
as well as HF & FM.
Also, the 8 - 24VDC input modification means the radio can now be used
with the external power simultaneously
with the batteries so that you don't lose your preset stations if
the external power is interrupted.
It can also be made to trickle charge
internal Ni-Mh batteries (don't do this if you are
using non-rechargeable batteries).
Note - This mod is suitable only if the radio is to be used
mostly with external power - reason, the combination of using
lower voltage rechargeable batteries and loss across an isolating diode
means the radio is only seeing about 4.5V instead of 6V, therefore
onset of low voltage shutdown will occur after fewer hours use.
Also, depending on the quality/complexity of the radio circuitry,
lower operating voltage can result in impaired reception
performance. Not applicable to high end radios like
the Sony
ICFSW7600GR that
maintain internal operating voltages irrespective of battery voltage, up to their shut down
point, with internal DC-DC converter circuits.
Just a small handful of components costing less than $10
is all that is needed and the two mods improve the performance and
usefulness by a huge amount.
The accompanying photo show the new aerial input socket and the DC power
socket below the original 6V input socket.
Of course, these simple mods can work
with other radios too.
| External
power supply for the Sony ICFSW7600GR
and other 6VDC radios |
The
Sony like many others is operated from 6VDC and that's what
the radio's external power socket wants to see. And in
Sony's case they don't see fit to supply an AC power pack.
Problem.............
- while good 12VDC AC plug packs are very common, good regulated
6VDC ones are not, also
- it would be very useful to be able to operate the radio from the
caravan and/or vehicle 12V battery.
A simple solution to both is to make a 12VDC to 6VDC
reducer. This is easily done with $5 worth of parts
from Dick Smith, Tandy, Jaycar etc.
All you need is the appropriate plug for the radio and a socket to suit
your power supply, a 7806 regulator, tantalum capacitor and a small
enclosure (mine is an old lipstick type dispenser - see photo).
This makes for a compact in-line connection between radio and
power source.
Fortunately, the Sony uses a smallish (uncommon) size plug so
that it can't be accidentally confused with the larger diameter more common sizes
found on most 12VDC plug packs.
Now, using this reducer, any voltage between 9 and 30VDC can be
used with the radio. The output is maintained at a
constant 6VDC.
The current capability of the
regulator (which is rated at 1A max,15W
dissipation) will depend on input voltage and size of heatsink
used. In my case with a nominal 12VDC input and
<250mA output, just a small one is needed which is obviously
contained within the lipstick dispenser.
| My
present receivers (the better ones) |
|
| |
|
|
| Icom R71A |
|
100
- 30000 kHz AM / SSB |
| Icom R7000 |
|
25 - 2000 MHz AM / FM / SSB |
| Sony ICFSW7600GR |
|
150
- 29999 kHz AM / SSB & 76 - 108
MHz FM |
| |
|
|
| My
original from long long ago |
|
It
was a Nordmende from West Germany,
a better than average portable radio in its day
(early ' 60s).
A three band 9 transistor radio covering,
LW - 160 - 280 kHz
MW - 510 -1650 kHz
SW - 1500 - 3500 kHz
Case was vinyl covered plywood
|
 |
|
|
|
|