The Mermaid, The Witch, And The Sea

Maggie Tokuda-Hall


Walker Books

September 2020

$18.99 AU

416p pb

ISBN: 978-1406395501

return to reviews list

The Mermaid, the Witch and the Sea is a romantic fantasy that follows two different girls and their stories. Evelyn Hasegawa is an imperial, someone with a high ranking in the Known World, with parents who question and doubt her abilities. She is then placed on the Dove, a pirate ship that takes her to an arranged marriage she dreads. This is where she meets Flora, an orphan girl who takes on the identity of Florian; a man of strength to gain the respect and protection of the crew. Through the dangers of sea and land, the two girls find a deep bond and start to seek the love that eluded them. 

I have to admit, this book was an interesting read. The plot of a fantasy filled with love and pirates was such a great idea to me that I did not hesitate to start reading. This book has so much potential to it. There were parts where I questioned the authorís intention, for example, how Evelyn began to realise that Flora was a girl because of the smoothness of her neck. I enjoyed the scenes where the characters were on the brink of danger or threat, however, some scenes lacked in the action I was expecting, and I would have liked more descriptions of the characters. I would recommend this book to those who love fantasy and romance, especially those who like the slow burn between the two love interests. 

Jirah, age 15


If you have read this book and would like add your comments below please email your review to YARR-A